Reading Time: 8 mins #
This post may contain affiliate links.
The birthday card fell out of a box. One of those boxes you move three times before finally opening. Heavy cream cardstock with a hand-drawn fox on the front because she knew I collected fox things. Inside, her handwriting: “To another year of bad decisions and good wine. Love you, weirdo.”
The date: March 2019.
I stood there in my hallway holding this artifact from a version of my life that felt both immediate and impossibly distant. We had the best friendships then. The kind where you don’t go three days without talking. Where inside jokes accumulate faster than you can catalog them, where “I need you” means the other person is already getting in the car.
I pulled out my phone. Scrolled to her name. We last texted 14 months ago, 11 months before that. I did the math going backward. The gap between contacts had been growing for years. Months became seasons, and seasons became years. There was no fight, betrayal, or any moment we could point to and say, “That’s when it ended.”
Just drift. Slow and quiet. The way friendships die when nobody actually kills them.
What We Were
College roommates, then post-grad roommates, then neighbors in the same city for six years after that. Sarah knew things about me that my family didn’t. Knew them because she was there when they happened. The job I got fired from. The relationship that ended badly. The panic attack in the Target parking lot over nothing and everything.
She was the person I called when good things happened. The person whose opinion I valued before making decisions. The person whose couch I slept on when my apartment flooded, whose hand I held in the emergency room, whose terrible taste in reality TV I pretended to judge while watching every episode with her.
We had a connection that felt permanent. Integral. Load-bearing in the fabric of who I was.
I can tell you her coffee order from memory. Can still hear exactly how she laughed at things that weren’t funny to make me feel funnier.
Know the specific way she’d say my name when she was about to tell me something I didn’t want to hear.
All present tense in my memory. All past tense in my life.
The Inflection Point That Wasn’t
I keep looking for the moment it broke. There isn’t one.
She moved first. New job three states away. We promised distance wouldn’t matter. Visited twice that first year. FaceTime every week. Then every other week, when something important happened, and finally when we remembered.
My life kept moving. New job, new relationship, new routines that didn’t include her. Her life moved differently. Marriage, pregnancy, a whole trajectory I experienced through Instagram squares and occasional phone updates.
We didn’t grow apart in personality. We grew apart in proximity and pace. She needed to talk about nursery colors and sleep training. My concerns were about career pivots and about getting a dog. Neither of us was wrong. We weren’t solving the same problems anymore.
[The Weight of a Draft | moneycatzzz.com]
The drift accelerated through these life stage divergences. Conversation became harder. Required more context, more catching up on missed months before we could get to the actual thing we wanted to talk about. The effort of maintaining friendships grew, while organic opportunities for maintenance disappeared completely.
Meaningful connection requires intentional design. Priya Parker rightly concludes that college gave us scaffolding: shared dorm, overlapping classes, proximity by default, but adult life removed every support. We tried to maintain the friendship through pure affection, but that proved insufficient when we were living in different time zones and facing different crises.
We needed scaffolding, and we had none. The friendship hung suspended on goodwill and history. That can’t hold indefinitely.
The Deceleration I Can Map
I can trace the slowing with precision now that I’m looking at it honestly.
2018: Weekly calls, multiple text exchanges daily
2019: Biweekly calls, texts every few days
2020: Monthly calls, weekly texts (pandemic briefly reversed the drift, then accelerated it)
2021: Quarterly calls, texts when something major happened
2022: Two phone calls total, texts for birthdays
2023: One call. Texts that said “we should catch up” without suggesting when
The math of drift is exponential, not linear. Each gap makes the next gap easier. The longer you go without talking, the higher the barrier to restarting becomes. You’re not just bridging the time since last contact. You’re bridging accumulated change, explaining who you’ve become in her absence, catching up on years while pretending it’s been weeks.
Research from the University of Kansas found it takes roughly 200 hours to develop a close friendship as an adult. I did the math. At our current rate of contact, rebuilding what we had would take six years, or longer. That timeline made the loss feel geological.
The Unsent Messages
I’ve written to her seventeen times in the last fourteen months. I haven’t sent a single one.
Draft after draft in my notes app. Some were long, trying to explain the drift and ask if we could course-correct. Some were short, pretending we could pick up where we left off. Some were honest about how much I miss her. Some pretended I was checking in casually.
None sent. Each one read and deleted or left in drafts until I wrote the next one.
The problem wasn’t finding words. The problem was not knowing what I was asking for.
Did I want to restart the friendship? Did I want closure?
Did I want to know she remembered me the way I remembered her?
Was I reaching out to her or to the person I used to be when she was still in my life?
James Carse writes in Finite and Infinite Games about relationships as finite (they have endpoints) versus infinite (they continue indefinitely). Our friendship is stuck in this weird between state. It’s not finished the way a friendship ending after a fight is. But it’s not continuing either.
The game is technically still in play, but both players left the field years ago. Nobody called it. We’re just both playing other games now.
Every unsent message was me trying to restart a game that might no longer exist.
What the Numbers Say About Loss
Dunbar’s number suggests we can maintain five close friendships at any given time. Five. Not fifty. Five intimate relationships outside of family and romance where we can sustain real depth.
I looked at my life honestly. My current count: three. Four if I’m generous about what counts as close.
That means I have capacity. Room for her. I chose to let one of five precious slots go empty rather than fight for what was dying. When there are only five, losing one is twenty percent of everything. That’s not a rounding error. That’s a profound loss.
Dr. Vivek Murthy, the U.S. Surgeon General, warned in 2023 that loneliness is an epidemic. He wasn’t being abstract: it’s people with empty slots in their Dunbar five who don’t know how to fill them because filling them would require 200 hours with someone new or fighting the drift with someone who already matters—both feel impossible when you’re already overwhelmed.
The loneliness I feel isn’t from being alone. It’s from having had something this specific and irreplaceable and watching it dissolve while I did nothing. It’s knowing that her particular way of knowing me exists nowhere else now. Nobody else has that history or speaks that language.
She was one of five. Losing her wasn’t just losing a friend. I was losing 20% of my capacity to be deeply known.
The Parallel Universe I Can’t Stop Imagining
Matt Haig’s The Midnight Library highlighted Nora Seed living out all the lives she could have had if she’d made different choices. Every book in the library is a different version of her life. Each is a different door she could have walked through.
I think about the library, the version of my life where I fought the drift.
In that universe, I sent one of the seventeen messages. She responded. We had an awkward first call where we both admitted it was weird and that we’d let too much time pass. Then a second call that felt more normal. Then we built a new understanding: first Sunday of every month, always. No excuses. Put it in the calendar like the important thing it is.
In that universe, we’re still close. Different than college close, but real. She knows about my life in real time, not just through annual updates. I know her kids’ personalities, not just their names. The connection survived because one of us decided it was worth the discomfort of acknowledging it was dying and needed saving.
[Sarah-Shaped Absence | moneycatzzz.com
That universe feels so close I can almost touch it, as if I could still access it if I just sent the right message today.
But I don’t know if that’s true. Maybe in the real universe where I sent the message, she didn’t respond. Or responded politely, but nothing changed. Or we had one catch-up call, then drifted again because the structural problems still existed, and good intentions aren’t structure.
Fighting the drift wouldn’t have worked. Some friendships are seasonal, and trying to force them into a perennial makes both people feel guilty about a natural ending.
I can’t know. That’s the part that sits heaviest. The uncertainty. Did I lose her because I didn’t fight hard enough, or did I lose her because sometimes proximity in your twenties creates bonds that can’t survive the thirties? Is this my failure or just what happens?
The Box, Still Open
The birthday card is on my desk now, out of the box. Fox is looking at me with that hand-drawn smile.
“To another year of bad decisions and good wine.”
We don’t make bad decisions together anymore. Haven’t shared wine in four years. The “we” that card refers to doesn’t exist in the present tense.
I could text her right now. Could photograph the card, send it, say “found this, made me think of you.” Let that be the opening that leads somewhere or nowhere.
I probably won’t.
Not because I don’t miss her, but because I don’t know if the person I miss still exists. She’s changed in the years of drift. So have I. The friendship I’m grieving might be with someone who isn’t there anymore, and contacting her now would confirm that the loss is complete.
Or I’m wrong. Maybe she’d love to hear from me — maybe she has her own box of artifacts, her own guilt about the drift, and her own drafted messages she never sent.
The not-knowing is its own kind of loneliness. Worse than the loss itself sometimes. At least with endings, you can grieve cleanly. This is grieving something that might not actually be dead, which makes the grief feel premature and permanent simultaneously.
The card is still on my desk. The message is still unsent. The drift continues.
Somewhere in the essay I’m writing, there’s a version of me who fought for this.
In this universe, I’m sitting here without knowing. With the specific ache of Sarah-shaped absence. With the birthday card from 2019 that says “love you, weirdo” in her handwriting.
I loved her too. Love her still, in the past-tense way you love people who drift out of reach.
The box is still open. I should close it. I probably won’t.
Reading Guide to the Universe's Silence
Finite and Infinite Games
The Art of Gathering
The Midnight Library
Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. We only recommend products we believe in, and we may receive a commission at no cost to you! Thank you for your support!
Acknowledgment: Cover Image by moneycatzzz.com
Disclaimer: The information is provided for general information only – moneycatzzz.com makes no representations or warranties in relation to the information, including but not limited to any representation or warranty as to the fitness for any particular purpose of the information to the fullest extent permitted by law. While every effort has been made to ensure that the information provided in this article is accurate, reliable, and complete as of the time of writing, the information provided in this article should not be relied upon to make any financial, investment, real estate or legal decisions. Additionally, the information should not substitute advice from a trained professional who can take into account your personal facts and circumstances, and we accept no liability if you use the information to form decisions.
